Your Source for Learning
Technology, Strategy, and News
    [Forgot Password?]
ARTICLES      
RSS feed RSS feed

Beginning Instructional Authoring: Decide What to Leave Out

"Don’t leave learners completely passive. Watching PowerPoint slides is a pretty passive experience. If the message is concise, the narration is really interesting, and there are interesting and relevant graphics, you can keep learners engaged -- for a brief time. You will get better results by considering some less technical ways to increase engagement, even if you aren’t quite ready to add higher levels of interactivity."

Numerous authoring tools can import PowerPoint slides, including Articulate Presenter and Adobe Presenter. What you put on these slides becomes part of the e-Learning content, so it’s pretty darn important.

Creating effective, PowerPoint-based e-Learning requires thinking in some new ways. Often, the most important part of creating PowerPoint slides is deciding what to leave out. In this month’s column, I’m going to take this approach to thinking about content.

What not to do when developing PowerPoint for e-Learning

  1. Don’t design slides that look like PowerPoint slides. Your slides shouldn’t look like typical (boring) bullet-point-driven presentation slides (Figure 1):

     

    typical bullet point slides

    Figure 1. Typical boring bullet points for a presentation

     

    Instead, make them look like e-Learning content (Figure 2):

     

    slides with graphics and images

    Figure 2. The same information, in visual form.

 

  1. Don’t present learners with a wall of text. If you want learners to read a lot of text, provide them with downloadable documents. Instead of massive amounts of text, put a relevant image or a little bit of text on the screen, and use narration to explain what is on the screen. Ask yourself what the least amount of text you can use in order to facilitate learning is. PowerPoint is a visual communications tool. Use relevant:

    • Images

    • Drawings

    • Screenshots

    • Graphs and charts

    PowerPoint 2007 and 2010 SmartArt provides some visually appealing ways to present text content. (That’s what I used to make the job analysis graphic in Figure 2.)

    For example, Figure 3 is a slide with faaaaaar too much text.

     

    slides with a lot of text

    Figure 3. Way too much text.

     

    The first problem with Figure 3 is that all this text is boring. Zzzz. The second problem is that learners will be reading your slides. Humans are unable to read and listen to narration at the same time. In addition, humans read faster than narrators talk. If the narrator reads what’s on each slide word for word (research has shown this to be a huge no-no), learners will finish reading each slide before the narrator finishes reading it aloud.

  1. Don’t leave learners completely passive. Watching PowerPoint slides is a pretty passive experience. If the message is concise, the narration really interesting, and there are interesting and relevant graphics, you can keep learners engaged – for a brief while. You will get better results by considering some less-technical ways to increase engagement, even if you aren’t quite ready to add higher levels of interactivity.

    For example, ask a question on one slide (Figure 4):

     

    slide with one question

    Figure 4. Might this question raise the level of engagement?

     

    Then provide the answer on the next slide (Figure 5):

     

    answers to the previous question

    Figure 5. The answer is the payoff for their attention.

     


(60)
I appreciate this article

Comments

Login or subscribe to comment

Thanks Patti, for this. I appreciate this conversation. Have you considered taking this piece to a tutorial demo video. I sure would. I think this info is valuable. Sadly, so many faculty still rely on bullet points and exhaustive text to teach learners what they ought to know. I will share this piece on my blog for them to take notice.

http://atthelearningcurve.wordpress.com/
That's a great idea, erendira!
Nice article, very relevant!
Are we not surronded by increased vocbulary for all the new things we combine in our work these days... It will take some serious thought, but you have given me some great things to work on! Yes that Smartart is great, I need to get 2010 installed on my system now! :)
Thanks.
Oh I wanted to say im looking forward to your next article. Also what you said here, should also account for what you narate into the voice overs. Less is more if it is conscise and is backed up by the visual. It is easy to go off topic while talking about certain things.. great food for though..
Patti, this is terrific advice and very helpful in my efforts to support Marine classroom instructors and subject matter experts in elearning development. I read this article last year and eagerly awaited the promised "word surgeon" follow up but have never seen it. Can you point me in the right direction, please?

Related Articles

Making New Year’s Resolutions? Jane suggests ten for your consideration, from eliminating Clicky Clicky Bling Bling to dealing with clients who have made up their minds.
There is a simple process that will help you figure out what learners need to be able to do in the real world and then make sure they get adequate practice doing it during instruction. Here’s a “play along” article that shows you the process.
Some of the most frequently asked questions among instructional designers are the ones dealing with text, images, and narration and how best to use them together. There are many examples of combinations that do not work, but not so many explanations of the principles behind making the right choices. Here is a simple explanation of three of the most important principles.